6,7分的期刊也能虛構(gòu)評審人
國家自然科學(xué)基金委員會監(jiān)督委員會對上海大學(xué)陳志文等被撤稿論文涉嫌學(xué)術(shù)不端問題組織開展了調(diào)查,涉及論文如下:
論文1:“Zhiwen Chen*, Minghong Wu*, Chan-Hung Shek*, C. M. Lawrence Wu, Joseph K. L. Lai. Multifunctional tin dioxide materials: advances in preparation strategies, microstruc-ture, and performance. Chemical Communications, 2015, 51(13):1175-1184.”(標(biāo)注基金號11074161、11375111、41373098、41430644、11025526、11428410)
論文2:“Zhiwen Chen*, Chan-Hung Shek, C. M. Lawrence Wu. Insights from investigations of tin dioxide and its composites: electron-beam irradiation, fractal assessment, and mechanism. Nanoscale, 2015, 7(38):15532-15552.”(標(biāo)注基金號11074161、11375111、11428410)
論文3:“Zhixiang Hu, Dayong Chen, Jingyu Dong, Qi Li, Zhiwen Chen*, Dongguang Yin, Bing Zhao*, C. M. Lawrence Wu, Chan-Hung Shek*. Facile synthesis of hierarchical Mn3O4 superstructures and efficient catalytic performance. Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics, 2016, 18(38):26602-26608.”(標(biāo)注基金號11375111、11074161、11428410、11575105)
論文4:“Mei Wang, Liming Cheng*, Quanbao Li, Zhiwen Chen, Shilong Wang*. Two-dimensional nanosheets associated with one-dimensional single-crystalline nanorods self-assembled into three-dimensional flower-like Mn3O4 hierarchical architectures. Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics, 2014, 16(39):21742-21746.”(標(biāo)注基金號11375111、11074161、11428410)
論文5:“Qingxiu Wang, Xianzheng Wu*, Lijun Wang, Zhiwen Chen, Shilong Wang*. Graphene-SnO2 nanocomposites decorated with quantum tunneling junctions: preparation strategies, microstructures and formation mechanism. Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics, 2014, 16(36):19351-19357.”(標(biāo)注基金號11375111、11074161)
經(jīng)查,陳志文作為涉事5篇論文中3篇論文的通訊作者和另2篇論文的實際聯(lián)系人,完成了5篇論文的投稿。其在推薦審稿人的過程中提供了虛假的郵箱地址,并使用這些虛假的郵箱,向雜志社回復(fù)了10份審稿意見。
返回小木蟲查看更多
京公網(wǎng)安備 11010802022153號
怎么發(fā)現(xiàn)的?
怪不得看到有灌水的文章,原來如此,自己審的
曲線趕超、進(jìn)步方法層出不窮,但是要正當(dāng),要經(jīng)得起時間檢驗。莫伸手,伸手必被捉。聰明反被聰明誤,留下笑柄。
RSC下的期刊被鄙視是有原因的,審稿這一關(guān)就放水,部分期刊推薦的審稿人大概率被完全采納,可以說是自掘墳?zāi)埂?/p>
PCCP也這樣?我多次投過PCCP,但是從沒感覺到,有送到我推薦的審稿人手里的情況。運氣問題?當(dāng)然這哥們實在是手段low了,也不怕出事,