decision letter 讓轉(zhuǎn)投其他期刊,是什么意思?后面還給列舉了4點評論,建議大修
Thank you for submitting your manuscript to European Polymer Journal.
After careful evaluation, and following reviewer assessment, I have determined there are other journals that may better suit your work.
The alternative journals I recommend are listed here:
Polymer Testing https://www.editorialmanager.com/POTE/
后面還給列舉了4點評論,建議大修:
Editor and Reviewer Comments:
Reviewer #1: 1.The manuscript needs proofread from a native English speaker.
2.The topic is too broad, but the manuscript is not correspondingly comprehensive enough, only hundred plus references. Take a simple example, papers from bioprinting-specific journals such as "Bioprinting" and "International Journal of Bioprinting" are limited, especially in recent 2 years.
3.On the other hand, the authors presented some of the latest development of biomaterials, more on ceramic and bioink but less on metal and polymer. However, it is unclear what points or insights they wish to provide. The current review is not critical enough, not indpeth, and very little has gone beyond current thinking in the field.
4.The authors should think clearly of the type of the review: comprehensive or in-depth? It is neither for the current manuscript. Since the topic of "latest development in 3D printing of biomaterials" is still interesting, a major revision is recommended.
請教大神,這現(xiàn)在我是應該如何去做?進行大修還是同意轉(zhuǎn)投呢?
返回小木蟲查看更多
京公網(wǎng)安備 11010802022153號
加油
,
根據(jù)意見修改,然后轉(zhuǎn)投
脣沒脮芒脫脨賂枚脠脮脝脷脝脷脧脼攏盧10脭脗3脠脮脰廬脟擄攏盧脪芒脣錄脢脟脭脷脮芒賂枚脝脷脧脼脟擄脥盧虜?shù)撁嵄R脪芒脳陋脥露攏盧脦脪脪陋脢脟脥盧脪芒脕脣碌脛祿擄攏盧戮脥脰鹵陸脫脳陋脥露鹿媒脠樓脕脣擄隆攏盧脢脟虜?shù)撁娒嚶久嵜兊撁撁惷惷炠T脛碌脛虜陸脰貓擄隆攏?br>,
審稿人雖然給了大修,但看來編輯給的轉(zhuǎn)投吧?你也沒法提交修改稿?
影響因子從6.1降到5.1,可以轉(zhuǎn)投。審稿意見估計也會轉(zhuǎn)過去,主要取決于審稿人當初有沒有選擇那個選項,轉(zhuǎn)投的一般被拒的概率比較小
大修,然后同意接收轉(zhuǎn)投。