拒稿鼓勵(lì)重投,求各位幫忙分析這份意見(jiàn)有戲不
投稿后一個(gè)月被拒,編輯回復(fù):
This to inform you that your manuscript was subjected to a peer referee for evaluation. As you will see from the enclosed comments, your manuscript, in its current form, was rejected for publication in our Journal. Refer especially to the Section Editor's file attached. As per our peer referee, the manuscript’s general impression is not corresponding to the journal's guidelines.
Hopefully, if you manage to rewrite the manuscript sufficiently, you are very welcome to submit it again as a new one.
兩個(gè)審稿人意見(jiàn)不一致,編輯回復(fù)如下,感覺(jué)態(tài)度比較友好,附了帶很多修改標(biāo)記的manuscript,這種情況修改回去有機(jī)會(huì)么?
Section Editor recommendation:
After receiving two extremely different reviews, I had to study this manuscript carefully.
Unfortunately, I must agree with reviewer 1. In this form, the manuscript is not ready for publication in xx Moreover, the number of issues and shortcomings present in the study is causing the need to thoroughly rewrite the article if the authors want to publish it in xx
The main issues are:
- weak English
- inappropriate usage of references
- the unsuitable level of introduction and discussion paragraphs
All of my comments are in the attached file.
Nevertheless, the presented technique is fascinating, so I am waiting impatiently for the new manuscript.
返回小木蟲(chóng)查看更多
京公網(wǎng)安備 11010802022153號(hào)
看得出來(lái)編輯還是希望你重投的,可能創(chuàng)新點(diǎn)很好,數(shù)據(jù)也不錯(cuò),只是寫(xiě)得不好,建議你重新寫(xiě)introduction和discussion,再拿出去潤(rùn)色下,附上潤(rùn)色證明。
圖表和語(yǔ)言問(wèn)題,找個(gè)潤(rùn)色的就好
很有戲啊
其實(shí)已經(jīng)潤(rùn)色過(guò)了,不過(guò)還好用的是AJE的高級(jí)潤(rùn)色可以多次潤(rùn)色的版本。多謝指導(dǎo)
,
其實(shí)已經(jīng)潤(rùn)色過(guò)了,不過(guò)還好用的是AJE的高級(jí)潤(rùn)色可以多次潤(rùn)色的版本。多謝指導(dǎo)!
只要編輯喜歡,希望就很大,我都看見(jiàn)過(guò)審稿人拒稿,編輯給大修,后面接收的。