 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
||
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
| 6 | 1/1 | 返回列表 |
| 查看: 2587 | 回復: 5 | ||
qiaopeisheng銀蟲 (正式寫手)
|
[求助]
catalysis communications審稿意見回來了，被拒，大家看看還值得改投么？ 已有4人參與
|
|
6月3號投了小cc，兩個月了審稿意見回來，一共三個審稿人，兩個拒掉一個大修，現在有點迷茫，不知道怎么辦了。 工作是關于紫外光催化的，Cu-TiO2的效應，表征到了單質銅的存在，還有顆粒效應。創(chuàng)新點有限，又是關于紫外光的，確實工作比較一般，拒掉也正常吧。意見里第一個非常嚴厲，第二個算是大修，第三個提了幾個意見然后拒掉了。大家看值得好好修改然后改投么？ Reviewers' comments on your work have now been received. You will see that they have raised sufficient major issues with your paper such that I must reject it for publication in Catalysis Communications. For your guidance, I append the reviewers' comments below. Thank you for giving us the opportunity to consider your work. Yours sincerely, Angelika Brückner, PhD Editor Catalysis Communications Reviewers' comments: Reviewer #1: The paper describes the photocatalytic activity of Cu-modified mesoporous TiO2 materials for formaldehyde degradation to hydrogen. The authors pretend to have discovered novel photocatalytic materials, and argue about a possible size-dependency of the activity which maximizes at some Cu loading. In reality, several papers have already described what the authors report (for example: J. Yu, Y. Hai, M. Jaroniec. Journal of Colloid and Interface Science, 357 (2011) 223-228; and, even more importantly, Anna V. Korzhak Journal of Photochemistry and Photobiology A: Chemistry 198 (2008) 126-134). There is not one detail that can be considered novel, and the discovery that metallic Cu is the active phase is based on a quite doubtful ex-situ procedure (DDT protection, when it's known that DDT can reduce metallic cations if used in excess to form several metal-thiol species). There are doubts whether this paper can be published anywhere, since it reports things that have been described in the literature already. Reviewer #2: The authors have completed an interesting study of the Cu/TiO2 system in relation to photocatalytic H2 production from aqueous formaldehyde solutions. I believe that this manuscript could be considered for publication pending the following changes. 1) The english in the introduction section is loose and of a conversation style rather than a scientific style. For example, the first sentences should be modified to read "H2 is expected to be one of the most important energy carriers in the future. Currently, approximately 95% of H2 is produced from hydrocarbons and coal." 2) The authors need to give more information about the formaldehyde solution they are using. Was the 2 wt.% solution of formaldehyde obtained by dilution 37 wt.% formaldehyde (which also contains methanol as a stabiliser), or was it obtained by dissolving paraformaldehyde in water? 3) The reduction of Cu(II) to Cu metal occurs in the absence of TiO2. Regarding the synthesis of Cu/TiO2, what evidence is there that all Cu(II) in solution is deposited on the TiO2? The authors present Cu 2p XPS data. but no supporting quantification information about the relative surface abundances of Cu, Ti, O, C and S. Does the optimum 1 wt.% nominal loading actually correspond to a 1 wt.% actual loading. XPS or XRF Cu/Ti ratios would have been useful in this regard. 4) UV-Vis absorbance spectra would have been useful for probing the presence of Cu(II), Cu(I) or Cu(0) on the surface of TiO2. Much of the evidence in this paper to confirm the presence of Cu metal was performed in the presence of a capping agent, dodecanethiol. I would like to see XPS and TEM images for the or the Cu/TiO2 photocatalysts in the absence of the capping agent as a comparison, or to at least have some text describing that data. Overall, this is good work that needs a bit more fine tuning and elaboration before publication. If the authors are willing to consider and the address the above points, I think this paper will be acceptable for publication in CATCOM. Reviewer #3: The authors report about a H2 evolution reaction from aqueous formaldehyde over in-situ deposited copper nanoparticles onto mesoporous TiO2. Unfortunately, I cannot recommend the present manuscript for publishing in CATCOM due to the following reasons: 1. In my opinion, the reported results lack in innovative value, since such UV-light induced H2 generation over similar photocatalytic systems have been published earlier, also with focus on the Cu salt concentration and the resulting particle sizes (see e.g. P. Gomathisankar et al. "Enhanced photocatalytic hydrogen production from aqueous methanol solution using ZnO with simultaneous photodeposition of Cu", Int. J. Hydr. Ener. 38 (2013) 11840-11846 or Choi et al. "Hydrogen production from methanol/water decomposition in a liquid photosystem using the anatase structure of Cu loaded TiO2", Int. J. Hydr. Ener., 32 (2007) 3841-3848). Concerning the practical application, it would be interesting to test also the visible-light activity e.g. by use of optical filters as the Cu nanoparticles exhibit plasmonic absorption and might be used as visible-light photocatalyst as well (demonstrated in Gomathisankar et al.). 2. The manuscript is not well structured as within the first part of photoactivities the authors often refer to the structural properties of the catalysts described in the second part. Besides, English spelling and grammar should be improved as well. 3. The light absorption properties (UV-vis spectra) of the catalysts would be interesting as well, especially a comparison of the protected (DDT) and non-protected samples in order to demonstrate the effect of absorption changes under catalytic conditions. The data of at least one unprotected sample should also be added to the XRD and XPS results. In case of XPS, often lower binding energies are detected due to a fast reduction of Cu(II) by introduction of the sample into the high vacuum chamber (see Irie et al. "Visible light-sensitive Cu (II)-grafted TiO2 photocatalysts: activities and X-ray absorption fine structure analyses." The Journal of Physical Chemistry C 2009, 113 (24), 10761-10766). 4. At last, from my point of view one should focus on the main results, so that minor important facts such as the influence of anion are mentioned only in the supporting information. |
回復此樓» 猜你喜歡
» 本主題相關價值貼推薦，對您同樣有幫助:
Catalysis Science & Technology，審稿意見是Reject & Resubmit,還要不要修改
已經有14人回復
- Catalysis Science & Technology，審稿意見是Reject & Resubmit
已經有4人回復
- Catalysis Communications投稿求助！�。。。。。。�！
已經有8人回復
- 投Catalysis Communications了，大修， 修改稿上傳后，收到編輯郵件又叫我修改提交
已經有10人回復
- Applied Optics被拒
已經有4人回復
- 【笑話一則，輕松一刻100】The Choice of Word
已經有44人回復
- Applied Catalysis A投稿問題
已經有15人回復
- Physical Review A 拒稿，改投求助！
已經有10人回復
- OE審稿怎么這么慢
已經有10人回復
- chemical communications小修，審稿人意見請教
已經有8人回復
- 求Synthetic Communications 的投稿經驗
已經有9人回復
- ACS Catalysis 投稿求助~
已經有15人回復
- 【求助】請大家?guī)臀铱纯碅pplied Catalysis B 的審稿意見吧，謝謝啦
已經有14人回復
- Chemical communications 投稿求助-大家一起給點力 謝謝
已經有14人回復
ll550
木蟲 (職業(yè)作家)
- 應助: 259 (大學生)
- 金幣: 4586.3
- 散金: 230
- 紅花: 34
- 帖子: 3331
- 在線: 767小時
- 蟲號: 3180771
- 注冊: 2014-05-05
- 專業(yè): 馬、恩、列、斯思想研究
2樓2014-08-02 19:45:45
自私的貓1988
榮譽版主 (文壇精英)
- 應助: 4800 (副教授)
- 貴賓: 6.746
- 金幣: 50040.4
- 散金: 11517
- 紅花: 256
- 沙發(fā): 134
- 帖子: 11684
- 在線: 1473.7小時
- 蟲號: 2004083
- 注冊: 2012-09-16
- 性別: GG
- 專業(yè): 有機分子功能材料化學
- 管轄: 論文投稿
3樓2014-08-02 20:19:42
20091783
版主 (職業(yè)作家)
努力的蟲子
- 應助: 323 (大學生)
- 貴賓: 0.221
- 金幣: 22721.1
- 散金: 1427
- 紅花: 27
- 沙發(fā): 1
- 帖子: 3758
- 在線: 408.5小時
- 蟲號: 2396836
- 注冊: 2013-04-02
- 性別: GG
- 專業(yè): 金屬結構材料
- 管轄: 材料工程
4樓2014-08-02 21:08:32
5樓2014-08-06 16:43:40
arthas_007
木蟲 (著名寫手)
- 應助: 225 (大學生)
- 金幣: 4765.8
- 散金: 1016
- 紅花: 66
- 帖子: 2055
- 在線: 374.1小時
- 蟲號: 1324253
- 注冊: 2011-06-16
- 專業(yè): 催化化學
6樓2020-05-27 14:02:21
相關版塊跳轉
我要訂閱樓主 qiaopeisheng 的主題更新
| 6 | 1/1 | 返回列表 |
| 最具人氣熱帖推薦 [查看全部] | 作者 | 回/看 | 最后發(fā)表 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
[考研]
 一志愿070300浙大化學358分，求調劑！
+3
|
酥酥魚.. 2026-03-21 | 3/150 |
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
[考研] 生物學071000 329分求調劑 +4 | 我愛生物生物愛?/a> 2026-03-17 | 4/200 |
|
|
|
[考研] 【考研調劑】化學專業(yè) 281分，一志愿四川大學，誠心求調劑 +11 | 吃吃吃才有意義 2026-03-19 | 11/550 |
|
|
|
[考研] 307求調劑 +3 | 余意卿 2026-03-18 | 3/150 |
|
|
|
[考研] 266求調劑 +3 | 哇呼哼呼哼 2026-03-20 | 3/150 |
|
|
|
[考研] 279分求調劑 一志愿211 +14 | chaojifeixia 2026-03-19 | 15/750 |
|
|
|
[考研] 299求調劑 +6 | △小透明* 2026-03-17 | 6/300 |
|
|
|
[考研] 332求調劑 +4 | ydfyh 2026-03-17 | 4/200 |
|
|
|
[考研] 一志愿華南師大 070300（化學）304分求調劑 +3 | 0703武芊慧雪304 2026-03-18 | 3/150 |
|
|
|
[考研]
 材料與化工 322求調劑
+4
|
然11 2026-03-19 | 4/200 |
|
|
|
[考研] 環(huán)境工程調劑 +9 | 大可digkids 2026-03-16 | 9/450 |
|
|
|
[考研] 廣西大學家禽遺傳育種課題組2026年碩士招生（接收計算機專業(yè)調劑） +3 | 123阿標 2026-03-17 | 3/150 |
|
|
|
[考研] 281求調劑（0805） +14 | 煙汐憶海 2026-03-16 | 25/1250 |
|
|
|
[考研] 材料與化工求調劑 +7 | 為學666 2026-03-16 | 7/350 |
|
|
|
[考研] 考研求調劑 +3 | 橘頌. 2026-03-17 | 4/200 |
|
|
|
[考研] 085601求調劑 +4 | Du.11 2026-03-16 | 4/200 |
|
|
|
[考研] 考研調劑 +3 | 淇ya_~ 2026-03-17 | 5/250 |
|
|
|
[考研]
11408 一志愿西電，277分求調劑
+3
|
zhouzhen654 2026-03-16 | 3/150 |
|
|
|
[考研] [導師推薦]西南科技大學國防/材料導師推薦 +3 | 尖角小荷 2026-03-16 | 6/300 |
|
|
|
[考研] 318求調劑 +3 | Yanyali 2026-03-15 | 3/150 |
|