【懸賞金幣】回答本帖問(wèn)題，作者smallmice將贈(zèng)送您 5 個(gè)金幣

smallmice

應(yīng)助: 0 (幼兒園)
金幣: 5
帖子: 4
在線: 30分鐘
蟲(chóng)號(hào): 3544255
注冊(cè): 2014-11-18

[求助] 投了ICL給了rejected-and-resubmission allowed的意見(jiàn)，求助大牛們?cè)趺纯? 已有2人參與

編輯意見(jiàn)是這樣的
The review of the referenced manuscript, CL2015-2386, is now complete. I regret to inform you that based on the enclosed reviews and my own
reading of your manuscript, I am unable to recommend its publication in IEEE Communications Letters.

You may revise and resubmit your manuscript to IEEE Communications Letters. When you do so, please include a cover letter that indicates the
new submission is a revision of an earlier manuscript and the reference number of that prior manuscript. Also include as a supporting document a
point-by-point response to the comments of the reviewers and the editor. The responses to comments file must be uploaded in PDF format in the same
section in your submission as the body of your paper in ScholarOne Manuscripts, and not under the cover letter. Please also be aware that ALL
submissions to IEEE Communications letters must complete the Electronic Copyright Process.

If you decide to resubmit your manuscript you should complete the resubmission through the Manuscript Central. Click on "Manuscripts with
Decisions" under My Manuscripts on the left side of your Author Dashboard and then click on "Create a Resubmission" under the Actions Column next to
your manuscript.

Your resubmission will be due within 75 days and is due on 14-Feb-2016. Please ensure that your revision is submitted in a timely manner as the webbased
system will not allow a revision to enter the system after 75 days have elapsed. Please be aware that the time at which your revision permission will expire is 11:59 PM EST on the 75th day.

Note, that according to the IEEE COMML policy, the maximum number of permitted resubmissions after a Reject-Resubmission Allowed decision is one
(1) and the maximum number of permitted Minor Revisions is (2).

Additional comments include:
The paper was evaluated by three independent reviewers who pointed out
several issues to be addressed and/or clarified. The authors should revise
the paper accordingly in a possible resubmission.

Reviewer: 1
Comments to the Author
IEEE Communications Letters
In theory, this Letter gives a good solution to the resource allocation problem usually occurred in the context of cognitive multi-pair relaying
transmission, by use of a similar optimisation strategy to those widely used for sub-carrier allocation in multi-user ODFM context (although the cost
function varies).

In practice, however, how to find a so-called "central controller, which collects all the required information", as claimed by the authors at the end of
Section II? Especially, in a large cognitive networks with mobile users, how can a central controller (even if it exists like a genius), how can it determine
which users should be grouped to jointly perform Tx power allocation? Similarly, which relays should be chosen as a potential group used to serve the aforementioned users? With such regards, the reviewer does not believe that such a central resource allocation strategy is of any practical interest in real wireless systems. Instead, some distributed strategies are more promising.

On the other hand, to better demonstrate the necessity of such complex resource-allocation operations, could the authors compare the end-to-end
performance, e.g., in terms of sum date rate of secondary transmission, between the proposed transmission scheme and the simplest scheme with
fixed power allocation and random relay selection?

Reviewer: 2
Comments to the Author
In this article, the authors investigate the resource optimization
problem for the multi-user multi-relay decode-forward (DF)
cognitive radio networks. The reviewer has the following concerns:
1)The authors should include the structure of the document.
2)The reviewer thinks that it would be important to explain the reason why these parameters results were chosen. Also, the authors should include references of articles that consider the discrete particle swarm optimization (DPSO) algorithm and the traditional water-filling (TWF) algorithm in cognitive radio.
3)The authors should explain better the metric bandwidthpower product (BPP). How the use of this metric improves the spectrum efficiency?
4)The authors created so much variables, it is hard to follow the sequence through the paper. The authors should review all the text and try to write the article with the minimum of variables. For instance, the authors use R^{n}_{m,k}, c_m, c for the transmission rate.、
5)The authors should explain better the arrangement of the nodes in the network. It is hard to see the localization of the nodes with a expression as "3+0.2×rand[0, 1]".
6)What is the value of R_{max} in the numerical results?
7)Are the parameters of the numerical results normalized? What is the unit of the metric bandwidthpower product (BPP)? Is the rate requirement c in bpcu or bps?
8)How is the results for a scenario where the primary receivers accept a great quantity of interference? For instance with I_{th} = 15 dB.
9) The equation (11) must be rewritten, because for c different of one, the supposition is not valid. The authors should write the variable w_{m,k} as (P_{sm}+P_k)/((2^c-
1)sigma^2), so the equation is valid independently of sigma and c.

Reviewer: 3
Comments to the Author
The authors applied bandwidth-power product as a metric of optimization
and use joint optimal relay matching and greedy resource allocation (JRMRA)
algorithm as a solution. I am not sure about the novelty of the proposed
optimization and the proposed solution.
In general the paper is well written and helps the researcher in this field.
I did some search and I found the following paper, [R1] at the bottom, which is very close to this work, however the authors did not clarify their novelty to
this work in the introduction section. In some parts it is a straightforward
extension to [R1]
Also I have found the following paper, [R2], also the authors did shoe their
contribution over it.
In general the paper is well written and helps the researcher in this field.

總體來(lái)說(shuō)，第一個(gè)reviewer意見(jiàn)太犀利，第二個(gè)提的是細(xì)節(jié)性東西比較好回答，第三個(gè)對(duì)創(chuàng)新性提出了質(zhì)疑，各位大牛們覺(jué)得有沒(méi)有重投的必要

回復(fù)此樓

» 猜你喜歡

342求調(diào)劑已經(jīng)有3人回復(fù)
070300化學(xué)專(zhuān)業(yè)279調(diào)劑已經(jīng)有9人回復(fù)
求調(diào)劑：085600材料與化工，考材科基，總分319 已經(jīng)有20人回復(fù)
一志愿華東理工大學(xué)，080500學(xué)碩，317分，求調(diào)劑已經(jīng)有9人回復(fù)
一志愿a區(qū)211，085601-307分求調(diào)劑已經(jīng)有23人回復(fù)
合肥區(qū)域性重點(diǎn)一本招收調(diào)劑已經(jīng)有8人回復(fù)
材料調(diào)劑已經(jīng)有10人回復(fù)
288求調(diào)劑一志愿哈工大材料與化工已經(jīng)有13人回復(fù)
材料科學(xué)與工程339求調(diào)劑已經(jīng)有3人回復(fù)
化學(xué)308分調(diào)劑已經(jīng)有11人回復(fù)

1樓 2015-12-03 20:54:31

已閱回復(fù)此樓關(guān)注TA 給TA發(fā)消息送TA紅花 TA的回帖

ise_support

捐助貴賓 (小有名氣)

應(yīng)助: 19 (小學(xué)生)
金幣: 296.3
散金: 3120
紅花: 13
帖子: 194
在線: 217.1小時(shí)
蟲(chóng)號(hào): 3151708
注冊(cè): 2014-04-21
專(zhuān)業(yè): 外國(guó)語(yǔ)言

2點(diǎn)拙見(jiàn)
1，這篇文章已經(jīng)不能重投，這個(gè)期刊已經(jīng)拒稿。只能改投。
2，這個(gè)期刊建議改投的期刊出版的應(yīng)該是letter形式，作者是否能接受？能的話，按照審稿意見(jiàn)修改后可以改投。

發(fā)自小木蟲(chóng)IOS客戶端

贊一下(1人)

回復(fù)此樓

2樓2015-12-03 22:15:33

已閱回復(fù)此樓關(guān)注TA 給TA發(fā)消息送TA紅花 TA的回帖

zbconquer

木蟲(chóng) (正式寫(xiě)手)

應(yīng)助: 77 (初中生)
金幣: 1901.1
散金: 1105
紅花: 25
帖子: 843
在線: 411.7小時(shí)
蟲(chóng)號(hào): 693619
注冊(cè): 2009-01-16
性別: GG
專(zhuān)業(yè): 通信理論與系統(tǒng)

【答案】應(yīng)助回帖

感謝參與，應(yīng)助指數(shù) +1

引用回帖:

2樓: Originally posted by ise_support at 2015-12-03 22:15:33
2點(diǎn)拙見(jiàn)
1，這篇文章已經(jīng)不能重投，這個(gè)期刊已經(jīng)拒稿。只能改投。
2，這個(gè)期刊建議改投的期刊出版的應(yīng)該是letter形式，作者是否能接受？能的話，按照審稿意見(jiàn)修改后可以改投。
...

。。。。
“You may revise and resubmit your manuscript to IEEE Communications Letters.”
這叫reject and resubmit allowed, 差不多就是大改。

贊一下

回復(fù)此樓

3樓2015-12-04 00:51:57

已閱回復(fù)此樓關(guān)注TA 給TA發(fā)消息送TA紅花 TA的回帖

smallmice

新蟲(chóng) (初入文壇)

應(yīng)助: 0 (幼兒園)
金幣: 5
帖子: 4
在線: 30分鐘
蟲(chóng)號(hào): 3544255
注冊(cè): 2014-11-18

引用回帖:

貌似這個(gè)是大改形式吧

發(fā)自小木蟲(chóng)Android客戶端

贊一下(1人)

回復(fù)此樓

4樓2015-12-04 08:51:19

已閱回復(fù)此樓關(guān)注TA 給TA發(fā)消息送TA紅花 TA的回帖

smallmice

新蟲(chóng) (初入文壇)

應(yīng)助: 0 (幼兒園)
金幣: 5
帖子: 4
在線: 30分鐘
蟲(chóng)號(hào): 3544255
注冊(cè): 2014-11-18

引用回帖:

4樓: Originally posted by smallmice at 2015-12-04 08:51:19
貌似這個(gè)是大改形式吧
...

恩，關(guān)鍵是第一個(gè)review意見(jiàn)很難改

發(fā)自小木蟲(chóng)Android客戶端

贊一下(1人)

回復(fù)此樓

5樓2015-12-04 08:51:40

已閱回復(fù)此樓關(guān)注TA 給TA發(fā)消息送TA紅花 TA的回帖

gloomykeel

金蟲(chóng) (小有名氣)

應(yīng)助: 0 (幼兒園)
金幣: 515
帖子: 57
在線: 47.3小時(shí)
蟲(chóng)號(hào): 2201532
注冊(cè): 2012-12-23
專(zhuān)業(yè): 信息理論與信息系統(tǒng)

【答案】應(yīng)助回帖

我覺(jué)得reviewer 1 提出的問(wèn)題指出了你的方案不太適用于你論文中提出的場(chǎng)景，但是他不能確定是不是有更合適的場(chǎng)景，好好修改，找一個(gè)合適的應(yīng)用，自圓其說(shuō)就好了，旁邊實(shí)驗(yàn)室多數(shù)cl都是先reject-with-resubmit，然后修改之后中了，加油！

贊一下(2人)

回復(fù)此樓

6樓2015-12-08 15:47:12

已閱回復(fù)此樓關(guān)注TA 給TA發(fā)消息送TA紅花 TA的回帖

最具人氣熱帖推薦 [查看全部]	作者	回/看	最后發(fā)表

[考研] 一志愿西安交大材料學(xué)碩（英一數(shù)二）347，求調(diào)劑到高分子/材料相關(guān)專(zhuān)業(yè) +3	zju51 2026-03-31	5/250	2026-03-31 18:26 by 253863592
[考研] 張芳銘-中國(guó)農(nóng)業(yè)大學(xué)-環(huán)境工程專(zhuān)碩-298 +9	手機(jī)用戶 2026-03-26	9/450	2026-03-31 18:09 by 544594351
[考研] 330分求調(diào)劑 +6	qzenlc 2026-03-29	6/300	2026-03-31 16:44 by Wang200018
[考研] 322求調(diào)劑 +3	熹僖XX 2026-03-31	3/150	2026-03-31 16:32 by 記事本2026
[考研] 085601 材料工程 313分求調(diào)劑 +6	Ong3 2026-03-27	6/300	2026-03-31 15:18 by yanflower7133
[考研] 英一數(shù)一總分334求調(diào)劑 +4	陳陽(yáng)坤 2026-03-31	4/200	2026-03-31 14:22 by 記事本2026
[考研] 085600 295分求調(diào)劑 +13	W55j 2026-03-30	15/750	2026-03-31 13:29 by 王亮_大連醫(yī)科大
[有機(jī)交流] 甲基亞磺磺酸鈉和甲基磺酸酯反應(yīng)機(jī)理 10+3	kaobao456 2026-03-29	4/200	2026-03-30 23:16 by nBu鋰
[考研] 材料科學(xué)與工程 317求調(diào)劑 +7	JKSOIID 2026-03-26	7/350	2026-03-30 20:10 by 滴滴上岸呀
[考研] 0703本科鄭州大學(xué)求調(diào)劑 +7	nhj_ 2026-03-25	7/350	2026-03-30 12:44 by fangnagu
[考研] 295求調(diào)劑 +5	wei-5 2026-03-26	5/250	2026-03-30 08:34 by 探123
[考研] 275求調(diào)劑 +15	Micky11223 2026-03-25	20/1000	2026-03-29 20:44 by 唐沐兒
[考研] 299求調(diào)劑 +10	15188958825 2026-03-25	10/500	2026-03-29 17:51 by 王亮_大連醫(yī)科大
[考研] 332求92調(diào)劑 +8	蕉蕉123 2026-03-28	8/400	2026-03-29 10:46 by 周梓丹
[考研] 2026年華南師范大學(xué)歡迎化學(xué)，化工，生物，生醫(yī)工等專(zhuān)業(yè)優(yōu)秀學(xué)子加入！ +3	llss0711 2026-03-28	6/300	2026-03-29 10:26 by llss0711
[考研] 0856求調(diào)劑 +13	zhn03 2026-03-25	14/700	2026-03-29 08:13 by fmesaito
[考研] 壓國(guó)家一區(qū)線，求導(dǎo)師收留，有恩必謝！ +7	迷人的哈哈 2026-03-28	7/350	2026-03-28 16:47 by 催化大白
[考研] 304求調(diào)劑 +6	曼殊2266 2026-03-27	6/300	2026-03-28 14:10 by 唐沐兒
[考研] 265求調(diào)劑 +8	小木蟲(chóng)085600 2026-03-27	8/400	2026-03-27 22:16 by 無(wú)際的草原
[考研] 調(diào)劑 +3	李嘉圖·S·路 2026-03-27	3/150	2026-03-27 11:19 by wangjy2002