QSZWDSWWD

管理員

應(yīng)助: 0 (幼兒園)
金幣: 1.5
紅花: 1
帖子: 4
在線: 2.2小時(shí)
蟲(chóng)號(hào): 3704478
注冊(cè): 2015-03-02
專業(yè): 凝聚態(tài)物性I:結(jié)構(gòu)、力學(xué)和

[交流] 第一次投文章，此審稿意見(jiàn)有希望嗎？該怎樣回答問(wèn)題？已有2人參與

Dear Prof. Dr. Li:

Thank you for submitting your manuscript for publication in Energy & Fuels. It has been examined by expert reviewers whose reviews are enclosed. The reviewers have expressed serious reservations about this work that I don’t believe could be addressed through a standard major revision. In light of the comments received, I am unable to accept the manuscript for publication in Energy & Fuels.

However, if further experimentation, analysis, and revisions allow you to address the referees concerns in full we would be happy to consider a new version submitted as a resubmission to this manuscript. Please upload a point by point response to all reviewer comments if you decide to resubmit.

With sincere regards,

------------------------------------

Reviewer Comments to Author:

Reviewer: 1

Recommendation: Publish after major revisions.

Comments:
This manuscript describes blends of a bio-oil produced through hydrothermal liquefaction following a previously reported pretreatment step termed “chemical-biological” with aviation kerosene and aviation gasoline. The work is interesting, important in the highly active field of renewable aviation fuels, and warrants publication in Energy & Fuels, however it seems somewhat incomplete. The authors should address the points below prior to this work being published.
1. 。。。。。。。
2. 。。。。。。
3. 。。。。。
4. 。。。。。。
5. 。。。。。。。

Additional Questions:

Originality: Good

Technical Quality: Fair

Clarity of Presentation: Good

Importance to Field: Good

-------------------------------------------------------

Reviewer: 2

Recommendation: Publish after major revisions.

Comments:
The main issue with this work is that the researchers take a highly acidic material and use it in aviation fuel. No airline manufacturer would let this near any of the materials used in an aircraft. What I suggest it that the researchers take the HTL oil and remove or esterify the acidic content, to give a neutral fuel that could potentially be compatible - if the researchers could do that, then do the fuel properties of this fuel (and maybe compare to the acidic oil) then I think it could be reviewed again and perhaps published.

In addition I am a little unclear on the explanations given for the fuel properties which appear to be contradictory. I think more experimentation is needed to show what is going on here.

For example -
Section 3.3.2 is very poorly argued. We need to see more experimentation here. What components have gone into the aviation kerosene? We need experimental proof, as it seems you have dissolved a highly oxygenated species into the jet fuel and got the energy density to increase!

Section 3.3.3 you need to explain why the freezing point went down, again, if you are putting in low molecular weight oxygenates – maybe I can see that, but large energy dense alkanes?! I should point out that palmitic acid has a melting point of 60 degC! So the results in this section really don’t correlate with what was observed in the previous section. More experiments are needed to explain what has happened here. Also the flash point is now below the standards allowed, so this fuel really cant be used at all. Please explain why this is the case

Further issues:

Introduction – Please check all references, some of the papers cited are not the ones discussed.

Experimental – not sure what AR means

Table 1 and 2, figure 1 can all go in supporting information
Conclusions – no, this approach can not be used for aviation fuels. The too low flash points and high acidity tell us that.

Additional Questions:

Originality: Fair

Technical Quality: Poor

Clarity of Presentation: Good

Importance to Field: Poor

--------------------------------------------------------

Reviewer: 3

Recommendation: Publish after minor revisions.

Comments:
Very good paper.Need to add statistical analysis of the results example to include standard deviation for reproducibility

Additional Questions:

Originality: Excellent

Technical Quality: Excellent

Clarity of Presentation: Excellent

Importance to Field: Excellent

回復(fù)此樓

» 本帖已獲得的紅花（最新10朵）

QSZWDSWWD

» 猜你喜歡

找調(diào)劑已經(jīng)有3人回復(fù)
一志愿南昌大學(xué)324求調(diào)劑已經(jīng)有7人回復(fù)
材料專碩322分已經(jīng)有5人回復(fù)
材料與化工（0856）304求B區(qū)調(diào)劑已經(jīng)有12人回復(fù)
材料調(diào)劑已經(jīng)有10人回復(fù)
省雙一流重點(diǎn)一本大學(xué)招收調(diào)劑已經(jīng)有6人回復(fù)
321求調(diào)劑已經(jīng)有6人回復(fù)
288求調(diào)劑一志愿哈工大材料與化工已經(jīng)有26人回復(fù)
材料調(diào)劑已經(jīng)有5人回復(fù)
一志愿北交大材料工程總分358 已經(jīng)有4人回復(fù)

» 本主題相關(guān)價(jià)值貼推薦，對(duì)您同樣有幫助:

第一次投英文文章，回來(lái)意見(jiàn)——發(fā)呆中…… 已經(jīng)有112人回復(fù)
小弟第一次投稿，編輯意見(jiàn)如何回復(fù)（貌似大修）已經(jīng)有2人回復(fù)
審稿周期快，投稿難度小的材料類雜志已經(jīng)有20人回復(fù)
文章在第二次修改投出期間，所投雜志影響因子下降了1分左右，對(duì)投稿有影響嗎？已經(jīng)有2人回復(fù)
文章被拒，是否應(yīng)按審稿意見(jiàn)更改后再投已經(jīng)有7人回復(fù)
AM接收，第一次在此發(fā)帖，順便分享投稿過(guò)程已經(jīng)有108人回復(fù)
求電化學(xué)類審稿快一點(diǎn)，影響因子較低的SCI期刊！已經(jīng)有14人回復(fù)
文章歷時(shí)三年，多次被拒，終被RSC ADV接收，聊以記之，以饗蟲(chóng)友。已經(jīng)有376人回復(fù)
意見(jiàn)是退修再審，還有一些外審給的意見(jiàn)不明白，第一次投稿，望大蟲(chóng)們指點(diǎn)！已經(jīng)有5人回復(fù)
投ACS里面的一個(gè)雜志，大修，請(qǐng)教一些問(wèn)題已經(jīng)有30人回復(fù)
兩個(gè)審稿意見(jiàn)，我該怎樣應(yīng)對(duì) 已經(jīng)有6人回復(fù)
請(qǐng)問(wèn)電化學(xué)類的文章投到哪里好呢，第一次投英文的已經(jīng)有0人回復(fù)
俺的幾次投稿經(jīng)歷，希望對(duì)大家有幫助，謝謝！已經(jīng)有63人回復(fù)
談?wù)勛约哼@學(xué)期多次投稿經(jīng)歷，跟大家交流下，希望大家能進(jìn)來(lái)看看！已經(jīng)有53人回復(fù)
【又到論文投稿時(shí)】四篇文章，兩次拒稿信已經(jīng)有195人回復(fù)

1樓 2015-08-19 13:38:49

已閱回復(fù)此樓關(guān)注TA 給TA發(fā)消息送TA紅花 TA的回帖

QSZWDSWWD

兌換貴賓

應(yīng)助: 0 (幼兒園)
金幣: 1.5
紅花: 1
帖子: 4
在線: 2.2小時(shí)
蟲(chóng)號(hào): 3704478
注冊(cè): 2015-03-02
專業(yè): 凝聚態(tài)物性I:結(jié)構(gòu)、力學(xué)和

加粗的部分是什么意思？需要怎樣修改，謝謝

贊一下

回復(fù)此樓

2樓2015-08-19 13:41:15

已閱回復(fù)此樓關(guān)注TA 給TA發(fā)消息送TA紅花 TA的回帖

QSZWDSWWD

版主

應(yīng)助: 0 (幼兒園)
金幣: 1.5
紅花: 1
帖子: 4
在線: 2.2小時(shí)
蟲(chóng)號(hào): 3704478
注冊(cè): 2015-03-02
專業(yè): 凝聚態(tài)物性I:結(jié)構(gòu)、力學(xué)和

送紅花一朵

急需求救�。。。∏蟾呤�

贊一下

回復(fù)此樓

3樓2015-08-19 13:45:57

已閱回復(fù)此樓關(guān)注TA 給TA發(fā)消息送TA紅花 TA的回帖

yan_swjtu

超級(jí)版主

應(yīng)助: 142 (高中生)
金幣: 54.4
散金: 2113
紅花: 9
帖子: 1362
在線: 603.7小時(shí)
蟲(chóng)號(hào): 1260340
注冊(cè): 2011-04-09
專業(yè): 元素有機(jī)化學(xué)

★
小木蟲(chóng): 金幣+0.5, 給個(gè)紅包，謝謝回帖

對(duì)出現(xiàn)的結(jié)果進(jìn)行統(tǒng)計(jì)分析說(shuō)明是否是小概率的偶然，是否可重復(fù)

贊一下(1人)

回復(fù)此樓

4樓2015-08-19 13:50:30

已閱回復(fù)此樓關(guān)注TA 給TA發(fā)消息送TA紅花 TA的回帖

adist

實(shí)習(xí)版主

墨家行者

應(yīng)助: 8 (幼兒園)
金幣: 346.6
散金: 699
紅花: 4
帖子: 628
在線: 257.1小時(shí)
蟲(chóng)號(hào): 919196
注冊(cè): 2009-12-03
性別: GG
專業(yè): 腫瘤遺傳

★
小木蟲(chóng): 金幣+0.5, 給個(gè)紅包，謝謝回帖

Need to add statistical analysis of the results example to include standard deviation for reproducibility。
樓上說(shuō)的很好，直接翻譯就是需要統(tǒng)計(jì)學(xué)分析，尤其是試驗(yàn)的標(biāo)準(zhǔn)差，看結(jié)果是否具有重復(fù)性。

贊一下

回復(fù)此樓

itsoundslikeaflame

5樓2015-08-20 10:09:36

已閱回復(fù)此樓關(guān)注TA 給TA發(fā)消息送TA紅花 TA的回帖

QSZWDSWWD

主管區(qū)長(zhǎng)

應(yīng)助: 0 (幼兒園)
金幣: 1.5
紅花: 1
帖子: 4
在線: 2.2小時(shí)
蟲(chóng)號(hào): 3704478
注冊(cè): 2015-03-02
專業(yè): 凝聚態(tài)物性I:結(jié)構(gòu)、力學(xué)和

引用回帖:

4樓: Originally posted by yan_swjtu at 2015-08-19 13:50:30
對(duì)出現(xiàn)的結(jié)果進(jìn)行統(tǒng)計(jì)分析說(shuō)明是否是小概率的偶然，是否可重復(fù)

能具體點(diǎn)嗎？怎樣統(tǒng)計(jì)分析？
謝謝

贊一下

回復(fù)此樓

6樓2015-08-22 14:05:42

已閱回復(fù)此樓關(guān)注TA 給TA發(fā)消息送TA紅花 TA的回帖

最具人氣熱帖推薦 [查看全部]	作者	回/看	最后發(fā)表

[考研] 材料調(diào)劑 +5	一樣YWY 2026-04-01	5/250	2026-04-01 12:53 by wxiongid
[考研] 285求調(diào)劑 +5	AZMK 2026-04-01	5/250	2026-04-01 12:45 by wxiongid
[考研] 289求調(diào)劑 +17	新時(shí)代材料 2026-03-27	19/950	2026-04-01 12:11 by -迷了路啊路
[考研] 311求調(diào)劑一志愿合肥工業(yè)大學(xué) +14	秋二十二 2026-03-30	14/700	2026-04-01 11:45 by chemdavid
[考研] 335求調(diào)劑 +3	321* 2026-03-31	4/200	2026-04-01 00:00 by 321*
[考研] 286分調(diào)劑 +11	Faune 2026-03-30	13/650	2026-03-31 17:28 by michael2011
[考研] 材料與化工272求調(diào)劑 +25	阿斯蒂芬2004 2026-03-28	25/1250	2026-03-31 16:27 by hypershenger
[考研] 生物考研337分求調(diào)劑 +4	cgxin 2026-03-30	6/300	2026-03-31 14:18 by 記事本2026
[考研] 求調(diào)劑 +8	11ggg 2026-03-30	8/400	2026-03-31 13:56 by nanaliuyun
[考研] 081200-11408-276學(xué)碩求調(diào)劑 +4	崔wj 2026-03-31	4/200	2026-03-31 11:56 by jp9609
[考研] 320分，材料與化工專業(yè)，求調(diào)劑 +10	一定上岸aaa 2026-03-27	14/700	2026-03-31 10:47 by foria
[考研] 求調(diào)劑 +4	圖鑒212 2026-03-30	4/200	2026-03-31 10:20 by cal0306
[考研] 085601一志愿中山大學(xué)深圳材料工程330求調(diào)劑 +5	pipiver 2026-03-30	5/250	2026-03-31 07:37 by JourneyLucky
[考研] 一志愿食品科學(xué)與工程083200求調(diào)劑 +4	XQTJZ 2026-03-30	4/200	2026-03-31 04:10 by fmesaito
[考研] 303求調(diào)劑 +7	DLkz1314. 2026-03-30	7/350	2026-03-30 21:07 by peike
[考研] 329求調(diào)劑 +8	星野? 2026-03-26	8/400	2026-03-30 13:41 by chemdavid
[考研] 085600，材料與化工321分求調(diào)劑 +10	大饞小子 2026-03-28	10/500	2026-03-29 23:35 by 飛行日記西
[考研] 343求調(diào)劑 +6	愛(ài)羈絆 2026-03-29	6/300	2026-03-29 12:00 by 無(wú)際的草原
[考研] 332求92調(diào)劑 +8	蕉蕉123 2026-03-28	8/400	2026-03-29 10:46 by 周梓丹
[考研] 283求調(diào)劑 +7	A child 2026-03-28	7/350	2026-03-28 12:05 by zllcz